What Happens When You Become Violent During Shoplifting In New York?

Shoplifting is a serious offense in New York, and the criminal justice system is growing increasingly impatient with those who commit this crime. Even if you never threaten anyone or become violent, stealing a low-value item from a New York store could result in serious penalties. That being said, your penalties generally become much more severe if you become violent during a shoplifting attempt. A Bergen County criminal defense lawyer may be able to help you mitigate these consequences.

Alleged Shoplifter Accused of Ramming Security Guard with Shopping Cart 

In July of 2024, it was reported that an East Meadow woman had rammed a security guard with her shopping cart. Authorities also alleged that she had shoplifted prior to the attack. Officers arrived after receiving reports of a woman placing items in her cart and attempting to leave without paying. After being confronted by a security guard, the defendant allegedly struck him with her shopping cart and made a quick escape in a white SUV. The woman has not been located as of this writing, but she faces numerous charges if caught.

Shoplifting Becomes Robbery When You Use Violence 

The most important thing to understand is that when you use any kind of force while carrying out larceny (theft), it is no longer considered “shoplifting” under New York law. Instead, you will face penalties for “robbery.” In New York, you face robbery charges whenever you use force during theft. You may also face robbery charges if you merely threaten someone while carrying out a theft.

The penalties for robbery depend on the circumstances of your alleged crime. If you use any force, you face a class D felony and up to seven years in prison. If you carry out a robbery with at least one other person, cause injuries, or brandish “what appears to be” a firearm, you face a class C felony. The penalties for a Class C felony include a maximum 15-year prison sentence. If you cause a serious injury or arm yourself with a deadly weapon, you face a class B felony and up to 25 years in prison.

Even Non-Violent Shoplifting Can Result in Serious Penalties 

Although the most severe penalties are reserved for those who commit violent theft, non-violent shoplifting may also result in serious consequences. A judge may decide to put you behind bars for over a year for a shoplifting offense in New York. This is becoming especially common amidst an unprecedented rise in shoplifting, as many judges wish to “set an example” for others. 

Find an Experienced Shoplifting Defense Lawyer in Rockland County 

If you’ve been searching for an experienced shoplifting defense lawyer in Rockland County, look no further than Phillip J. Murphy, Attorney at Law. Over the years, we have helped numerous defendants throughout New York. You are not alone – whether you have been charged with shoplifting, violent crimes, a combination of both. Reach out today to discuss your potential defense strategies in more detail.

Sources: 

audacy.com/1010wins/news/state/shoplifter-rams-guard-with-shopping-cart-at-li-stop-and-shop

nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/PEN/70.00